Sale-leaseback
A Resurgence of Investor Confidence
Earlier this week, real estate professionals from over 70 countries gathered in Munich for the annual EXPO Real trade fair. After a muted year of investment volume, participants were eager to meet with peers to discuss prospective deals and the outlook for the market. The mood can be best described in two words: cautiously optimistic. After rising interest rates caused months of uncertainty and volatility, attendees finally feel stability is on the horizon. Below are three key topics discussed as delegates look ahead to 2025. Interest rates on the decline Monetary policy decisions on both sides of the Atlantic were a major topic at this year’s EXPO. The European Central Bank began cutting rates this summer, followed by the Federal Reserve in September. These rate cuts are an indicator that inflation is on track to reach its target level for price stability. As a result, we’ve seen the bid-ask spread between buyers and sellers narrowing as real estate values adjust to more realistic levels. For investors waiting on the sidelines for economic clarity, this has also served as the impetus to start deploying capital into new and existing assets. At W. P. Carey, however, we would caution that investors should not focus too much on the next interest rate decision. Instead, they should consider the more important factor – long-term borrowing costs. Real estate investors typically borrow on a long-term basis given the length of their leases, so short-term rate cuts won’t have as much of an impact as some are anticipating. New sectors growing in popularity Post-pandemic challenges in sectors including office and some segments of retail have made investors far more selective in terms of capital allocation. Industrial remains among the most popular asset classes as it continues to benefit from strong market fundamentals. The e-commerce boom and logistics sector’s key role in European supply chains remain long-term growth drivers, while the emerging trend towards nearshoring will provide manufacturing and logistics with a further boost. We’re also starting to see some newer sectors growing in popularity. Self-storage, cold storage, senior living, hospitality and data centers have emerged as attractive investments, with strong operating fundamentals and positive long-term growth potential. As investors continue the flight to safety to protect returns, we expect to see a shift in the sectors – and geographic markets – receiving the most capital. An uptick in sale-leasebacks in 2025 Despite some volatility, the overall environment for sale-leasebacks remains favorable, with high-yield debt and leveraged loans continuing to be expensive. The influx of cash from a sale-leaseback remains incredibly valuable for companies, supporting debt restructuring, strengthening balance sheets and providing capital for operating expenses and growth investments. In addition, we continue to see interest from private equity firms in sale-leasebacks as a means of financing new acquisitions or bolstering the growth of portfolio companies. Last year alone, approximately 75% of W. P. Carey’s investment volume was attributable to transactions with PE-backed companies and we anticipate a significant portion of this year’s deal volume will be as well. While it will take some time for the sale-leaseback market to recalibrate and reach its new normal, we are starting to see the green shoots of a more stable industry as we gear up for a busy fourth quarter. We remain “cautiously optimistic” heading into 2025 and look forward to continuing to find opportunities to help companies unlock capital from their real estate assets.
‘We’re Bullish On Net Lease Retail’
Investors are flocking to the net lease sector anew as the Fed pauses its rate actions and cap rates stabilize, W. P. Carey’s Michael Fitzgerald told GlobeSt. GlobeSt's Holly Amaya spoke with Fitzgerald at ICSC Las Vegas about the state of retail net lease and what has changed in the sector from last year. In this video, you’ll learn: Why he continues to be bullish on net lease retail, What an increase in cap rates has meant for investment, and How the sector will fare in 2024 and beyond. Watch now An interview with Michael Fitzgerald, W. P. Carey, and Holly Amaya, GlobeSt.com.
Countdown to ICSC Las Vegas
ICSC Las Vegas, one of the largest tradeshows for the retail industry, is on the horizon with an expected 30,000 attendees eager to network and reconnect face-to-face with industry leaders and peers. After a somewhat sluggish 2023, attendees will be looking to the conference to shed some light on the retail landscape and offer insights on new trends and opportunities within the sector. Consumer spending, retail vacancies and sale-leaseback activity will be among the most pressing topics discussed at the show. Here's an overview of each: Consumer spending remains steady Despite inflationary concerns, consumer spending has remained steady over the past year, as core retail sales, excluding gasoline, food service and auto vehicle purchases, increased by 3.3% at the end of 2023. As a result, demand for retail space has remained strong and the market is starting to see in uptick in new developer-built retail locations coming online. W. P. Carey has completed several deals that align with this trend – for example, the acquisition of 22 recently built and to-be-completed car wash facilities across the U.S., leased to Tidal Wave Auto Spa, a prominent car wash operator. With interest rates projected to decrease in late 2024, the market will likely continue to see a ramp up in new development over the coming months. Retail vacancies at record lows Strong demand for retail space has resulted in record-low vacancy rates, with total retail vacancy reaching 4.2% at the end of 2023. Low vacancy rates are a positive sign for investors like W. P. Carey as it provides greater confidence in long-term leases and the ability to re-lease vacant buildings if the need arises. However, it also means more competition for less space which is pushing retail rents significantly higher. This makes it more expensive for retailers looking to expand and acquire new space, which in turn increases operational costs. Sale-leaseback activity picks up With rents rising significantly, retailers – particularly those looking to grow their real estate footprints – will be seeking new ways to access capital. This will likely contribute to greater demand for sale-leasebacks, where a retailer sells its real estate to an investor (like W. P. Carey) for cash and simultaneously enters into a long-term lease. This is a valuable business decision for most retail companies because owning real estate can serve as a drag on their balance sheet. By unlocking the value of their real estate through a sale-leaseback, retailers can reinvest proceeds into their core competencies, leading to better overall returns and long-term growth.
Navigating Net Lease Retail
Rising interest rates, increased cap rates, and sluggish deal activity created changes in the retail market over the past couple of years. Indeed, the bid-ask spread left many retail net lease deals stuck in negotiations. “There was a time when buyers and sellers found themselves pretty far apart, trying to find a way to meet in the middle,” says Michael Fitzgerald, executive director and head of US retail at W. P. Carey. “During 2023, we saw volume slowdowns of traditionally marketed sale-leaseback deals, as some sectors experienced 50, 75, or even 80 basis point increases in cap rates.” However, at the start of 2024, Fitzgerald notes that he’s seen a stable flow of developer-fueled deals and a higher demand for liquidity. As the market progresses into 2024 and beyond, understanding its direction can help investors make more strategic decisions. Low vacancy rates, creating new opportunities A recent report found that retail vacancy rates are at their lowest level in two decades, as rents continue to rise. The report compared 390 retail marketers across the United States and found that the national retail vacancy rate sat at just 4%. According to Fitzgerald, low vacancy rates are a positive sign that provides confidence in long-term leases and the ability to quickly replace tenants. “Let’s say a fitness operator signs a 20-year lease,” says Fitzgerald. “If retail vacancies are low, that’s a positive for us if we need to re-tenant, as we can likely replace them with a new tenant at or above the original price without compromising our income stream.” He explains that W. P. Carey typically focuses on finding deals in markets with growing rents, such as Phoenix, versus smaller and less vibrant markets. “When you get into underwriting situations where vacancy rates are low, it often allows us to get more aggressive with the cap rate and other deal terms,” says Fitzgerald. Looking into 2025 and beyond Another factor that could contribute to an uptick in activity is merger and acquisition deals. An increase in M&A typically corresponds to an uptick in sale-leaseback activity, as firms leverage proceeds as part of the capital stack for new acquisitions. Overall, Fitzgerald remains optimistic about the coming months. “I think the retail market will continue to be strong because there’s always compelling fundamental reasons why retailers want to sell their real estate rather than hold it,” says Fitzgerald. He explains that it comes down to retailers not being real estate companies. Businesses can generate better returns for investors by investing in their core competencies, ie. running retail operations, and often find holding onto real estate is a drag on their cash and liquidity. As a result, he predicts continued demand from retailers for creative ways to access that liquidity – such as sale-leasebacks.
How Sale-Leasebacks Help PE Raise Capital in a Tight Market
Funding for growth, refinancing corporate debt, and merger and acquisition activities are top priorities for many private equity firms. A recent PwC report noted that 60% of CEOs plan to make at least one acquisition in the next three years. The report further explains that lower levels of M&A activity during 2023 created “pent-up buyer demand” moving into the current year. However, tapping into capital isn’t always easy when it is locked in assets. “It’s quite inefficient for private equity firms to have capital tied up in real estate assets that aren’t earning for them,” says Tyler Swann, managing director, investments at W. P. Carey. “An alternative is doing a sale-leaseback, which provides a much lower cost of accessing capital than traditional financing methods.” Understanding sale-leasebacks and their advantages can help private equity firms strategically manage growth funding, debt maturities and other capital needs. The advantages of sale-leasebacks With traditional financing strategies such as mortgages, terms are often shorter and exposed to higher market volatility. Accessing capital can also be time-consuming, a challenge for firms that need to move quickly for acquisition deals. That’s not the case with sale-leasebacks, notes Swann. “Sale-leasebacks are very flexible,” says Swann. “The processing time can be as short as 30 to 45 days between the initial call and the actual funding. It’s not unusual for us to get a call from a private equity firm saying, ‘We’re closing on a business in 30 days; can you be there to close with us as acquisition financing?’ And that’s something we can do.” He explains that capital uses also have very few restrictions, with the most common purposes being acquisition financing, dividend payments, and refinancing maturing debt. Misconceptions about sale-leasebacks As private equity firms consider sale-leasebacks, questions often linger regarding who qualifies for this type of financing. Many believe that because their real estate is in a secondary or tertiary market, or their asset doesn’t have a huge value, they won’t qualify. But according to Swann, that’s not necessarily true. “If you have a specialized manufacturing facility in a small market, you may think it won’t qualify because it’s not a high-quality warehouse in a market like Southern California,” says Swann. “Despite where an asset is located, if it’s profitable and contributing to the bottom line of a business, it could be a great candidate for a sale-leaseback.” As the market progresses through 2024, Swann expects sale-leaseback activity to continue upward, partly due to M&A activity and its flexibility to tap into capital quickly. “Every year, sale-leasebacks become a little more accepted in the private equity community as a source of financing,” says W. P. Carey’s Swann. “Ten or 20 years ago, corporate debt was by far the dominant option, but we continue to see an increase in sale-leaseback deals every year.”
Charting a Path Forward
The CFO role has evolved over the years, expanding from its traditional financial focus to a broad range of strategic responsibilities. Today's CFOs wear many hats – from financial planning to compliance and risk management and strategic decision-making, among many others. In an environment marked by rapid technology advancements, market volatility and regulatory changes, CFOs play a crucial role in guiding organizations through challenges to build resilience and maintain profitability. In this blog, we delve into CFOs’ top priorities for 2024, drawing from a recent Gartner survey, and explore how leveraging sale-leasebacks can unlock capital to address these priorities. 1. Leading Transformation Efforts Embracing technology and automation remains a top challenge for organizations. Recognizing the crucial role of technology in enhancing business efficiency, compliance and competitiveness, CFOs will focus more on leading digital transformation efforts, both within their departments and across the entire organization. CFOs are integral to driving business transformation, especially in evaluating the best initiatives to adopt and their contribution to the bottom line. As companies scale, continuous implementation of emerging technologies becomes essential for efficient growth management. 2. Evaluating or Improving Financial Strategy Managing the finance function is a core responsibility for CFOs, and is vital for business growth and continuity. With the current economic and market volatility, CFOs will focus more on evaluating and improving the finance function's strategy. A robust financial strategy is essential to meet short and long-term financial goals and ensure positive business outcomes. It offers a better understanding of the company's present financial situation, assesses potential risks, outlines income goals, identifies competencies, investment strategies and funding options necessary to realize those goals. 3. Improving Finance Metrics, Insights and Storytelling Understanding financial metrics and insights is crucial not just for CFOs, but the whole organization. As such, leveraging data visualization can help simplify complex concepts, streamline reporting and foster collaboration across the organization. This can enable companies to tell stories and drive better understanding of their messaging among core audiences, including investors, which can potentially boost valuation. CFOs will prioritize improving finance metrics, insights and storytelling to achieve these and other benefits. 4. Leading Change Management Efforts CFOs will also prioritize leading change management in 2024. Resistance to change among employees is a common challenge often triggered by factors like fear of the unknown, lack of trust in leadership or loss of control. Effective change management is thus vital to organizational success. Strategic leadership promotes consistency, builds employee trust, enhances cost management and enables organizational agility, among other benefits. 5. Optimizing Costs Optimizing costs is yet another area of precedence for CFOs in 2024. Strategic cost management is essential for the realization of organizational goals, especially in volatile times. Possible initiatives include, promoting cost-consciousness across the organization to reduce operating costs, adopting new technology and automation to address inefficiencies, embracing data-driven decision-making and improving vendor management. The Key to Make it All Happen The success of an organization's financial initiatives hinge on the availability of capital. Particularly in an uncertain rate environment, access to liquidity is essential in providing companies with flexibility and growth capital. For companies that own their real estate, sale-leasebacks offer an alternative capital source to support CFOs’ 2024 priorities. These transactions enable companies to access immediate funds while maintaining operational control of their facilities. However, several considerations must be addressed to determine the suitability of a sale-leaseback for a business. First, sale-leasebacks only makes sense if the company owns its real estate. Additionally, a strong credit profile is necessary and a willingness to commit to a long-term lease is essential. The W. P. Carey Solution With all the conditions met, a sale-leaseback is a handy strategy that CFOs can explore to raise the much-needed capital to support the above priorities. At W. P. Carey, we have helped many companies in North America and Europe leverage this financing solution for over 50 years. If you're considering unlocking capital for your operations this year through a sale-leaseback, contact W. P. Carey today!
Expectations for MIPIM 2024
MIPIM, the world's largest real estate conference, will get underway in Cannes next month with over 20,000 delegates expected to attend. As in years past, many will be looking for the conference to bring some clarity on what the real estate industry should be looking out for in the year ahead. While the industry outlook remains murky, investors entered 2024 with a sense of optimism. Here are the biggest questions delegates will be looking to answer at MIPIM 2024. Have Eurozone interest rates reached their peak? The market consensus is generally that the European Central Bank (ECB) has completed or is nearing the end of its rate hiking cycle. However, much to the disappointment of the market, the ECB did not give an indication on when rates would be cut. As a result, a continued upward pressure on yields and downward pressure on real estate valuations is expected through 2024. On a positive note, interest rates reaching their plateau should help jump start the investment market. Greater predictability will contribute to value discovery, cap rate stabilization and tightening bid-ask spreads. This will result in greater transaction activity and hopefully many discussions around prospective deals at MIPIM! What's the outlook for the European sale-leaseback market? Given borrowing costs are expected to remain high in 2024, sale-leasebacks will continue to be an attractive solution for companies to unlock the value of otherwise illiquid real estate assets. Furthermore, with a large share of speculative-grade debt expected to mature in 2025 and 2026, more companies will likely leverage sale-leasebacks for additional proceeds to get refinancing done. Sale-leasebacks offer permanent, long-term capital with no refinancing risk or balloon payments, which remains a very attractive alternative for companies in need of extra cash. In addition, M&A activity is expected to increase in 2024, with private equity firms sitting on over $2.5 trillion in dry powder. Typically when M&A activity increases, there is an uptick in sale-leaseback opportunities, as private equity firms are increasingly leveraging sale-leaseback financing as part of the capital stack for new acquisitions. How can the real estate industry make ESG commitments a reality? The rollout of the EU’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) has put increased pressure on real estate companies to both implement and report on their ESG initiatives. As a result, companies are developing strategic plans to create and maintain sustainable real estate portfolios while also preparing to meet upcoming compliance standards. The challenge the real estate industry faces today is turning commitments into reality. One of the most important steps companies can take is creating more efficient and automated processes for the procurement and management of ESG data. The use of business intelligence and building technology significantly enhances the data collection process, allowing companies to evaluate potential building improvements, review opportunities to reduce emissions and meet future reporting requirements. MIPIM offers a valuable platform for the industry to discuss new ideas and possible solutions related to ESG.
Looking into the Crystal Ball
2023 was undoubtedly a challenging year for the net lease sector. High inflation, rising interest rates and other economic uncertainty caused a notable decrease in overall transaction volume, sparking apprehension about the trajectory of the industry. However, there have been some signs of renewed life in the market. Most experts believe we have hit the interest rate peak and expect cuts to be made in 2024. In addition, dealmakers generally anticipate that the M&A environment will improve given the market has stabilized, which could bring more investment opportunities to the market. While no one has a perfect crystal ball about what the future will hold, there are certainly reasons for optimism in 2024. Here are three net lease market predictions for the year ahead. Boost in net lease deal volume fueled by projected interest rate cuts The U.S. Federal Reserve indicated in its latest summary of economic projections that three cuts may be coming in the year ahead. The cuts are expected to be slow and gradual and will be dependent on the state of the economy, but investors reliant on third-party debt are hoping for a much-needed reduction in borrowing costs to remain competitive. The signaling of rate cuts is positive news for the market as it means interest rates have most likely reached their peak. This should help the market stabilize therefore narrowing the bid-ask spread between buyers and sellers, leading to a more active deal environment in 2024. In addition, many investors who have stood on the sidelines in anticipation that there will be more favorable opportunities down the road are likely to start jumping back into the market in 2024 and new entrants are expected to join in. Uptick in private equity sale-leasebacks as M&A surges The dealmaking environment in 2024 is already off to a better start than 2023. Inflation has declined, interest rates have likely reached their peak and private credit has become more widely available for more kinds of deals, while traditional credit markets are starting to improve. Private equity firms are also sitting on an unprecedented amount of dry powder – $2.59 trillion – with mounting pressures to deploy that capital into new investments. As a result, M&A activity is expected to increase in 2024. Along with an uptick in dealmaking, savvy private equity firms are expected to continue looking for alternative strategies for growth given lingering economic and geopolitical uncertainties. One effective strategy is through the sale-leaseback of their portfolio company real estate, which allows private equity firms to unlock immediate capital to redeploy into other initiatives, such as new acquisitions or portfolio company growth. Typically, when M&A activity surges, sale-leaseback opportunities follow, so more private equity-backed real estate deals will likely emerge in 2024. Pandemic office trends remain while industrial holds steady More than three years since the start of the pandemic, the real estate industry has finally accepted that the office sector will not return to the way it was before – and hybrid- and- remote work models are here to stay. As a result, offices have lost much of their appeal for investors, with transactions declining more than twice as much as any other property sector in 2023. W. P. Carey announced its strategic plan to exit office last year, through the spin-off of 59 office properties into Net Lease Office Properties and an office sale program to dispose of the remaining on-balance sheet assets. This trend is expected to continue into 2024 and some office investors will likely start to look for alternative uses for office assets – such as residential or industrial. Industrial, on the other hand, will continue to perform well into 2024, as re-shoring and nearshoring provide a boost to the sector. While the asset class is showing some signs of softening post-pandemic as the need for robust inventory decreases, the long-term outlook remains positive. Moody’s Analytics CRE forecasts that annual rent growth for warehouse and distribution properties will track at approximately 5-6% per year over the next 10 years, suggesting that the sector has moved on from its huge boom into a steadier state of growth.
Where Will Net Lease Go in 2024?
In 2023, higher debt costs, a looming $2 trillion-plus wave of corporate debt coming due and other economic uncertainty have clouded the CRE outlook. And while the net lease sector, with its low risk and steady income, has weathered recent economic headwinds better than most, it’s not immune. Execution uncertainty was a central theme in 2023, reports Zachary Pasanen, managing director, investments at W. P. Carey. “With the ramp-up in interest rates, buyers and sellers have struggled to meet at a price that made sense,” he says, noting that a lot of deals after the first quarter had repricing challenges or re-trade concerns. In a competitive market, those who rely on debt financing have been constrained by higher rates. Investors, however, are still seeing cap rate expansion within certain sectors. Shifting Rates & Fundamentals With deals more difficult to come by, investors have re-focused on fundamentals. Pasanen notes that, with industrial, this has meant a refocus on rent growth and the assets “criticality.” There remains good demand for industrial assets, but investors should realize the changing fundamentals of the sector: it is no longer the “darling” product, attracting unlimited cheap capital in pursuit of properties requiring lower capex. Pasanen uses the word “retrenchment” for the asset class as people are getting smarter with rent growth projections following their internal modeling. “With the sector still offering a lot of attractive elements, there is no desire to move out of the sector,” he says. “Unlike office, we view industrial, particularly manufacturing, as profit centers: it’s where the widgets are made. We focus on good, underlying fundamentals but also where there’s criticality in the real estate.” The sudden shift in rates has caused a break in investor expectations, Pasanen says, with one-off, syndicators or family offices still pursuing at compressed numbers. Meanwhile, institutional investors are focusing on tenant credits and cap rates at 8% and higher. Outlook Pasanen notes there’s opportunity in sale-leasebacks for companies looking to raise capital. He says W. P. Carey has a successful history here, taking the time to understand a business to ensure they will be a good investment for the long haul. “No one has a perfect crystal ball, but we try our best and we've got a long history of underwriting credits that are sub-investment grade in nature, and we have a good track record in doing so.” Market expectations are leaning toward interest rate cuts in 2024, an outlook reaffirmed by the Fed’s latest announcement on December 13. Smart investors, however, should prepare for all situations and also have contingency plans for a long pause or even a rate hike if inflation kicks up again. With inflation and increasing interest rates making borrowing more expensive, will CFOs and fund managers continue to strategize on how to recalibrate their business and find that new normal? “I think it will actually be a big year in 2024,” he says. “The rise in interest rates happened quickly so if we have a long pause [on rate movement] the deal environment should become more normalized. When the behavioral element settles in we’ll see more normal investment activity.”