Sale-leaseback
Where Net Lease is Heading
With financing options restricted by interest rate uncertainty, corporate real estate sellers have been turning to sale-leasebacks. It’s easy to see why: these deals offer liquidity and immediacy. For the net lease sector at large, Tyler Swann, managing director, investments at W. P. Carey, is seeing US deal flow coming almost exclusively from new sale-leasebacks versus acquisitions of existing leases, a change largely driven by the changing capital markets landscape. CRE Psychology Playing Catch-up As interest rates have risen and asset values have fallen, the pricing expectations of sellers have not followed suit. That’s led the market to favor new sale-leasebacks as opposed to investment properties that are acquired from third-party landlords, Swann says. "There's a disconnect between what buyers can realistically pay given current capital markets and what a seller wants,” he says. “It takes time for psychological expectations of sellers to reset and I think we haven't seen that play out just yet, which is why those existing lease deals haven't really been moving or coming to market at all.” New sale-leaseback sellers are more realistic, comparing and choosing the costs of such a deal versus the current cost of capital, especially the added expense of raising debt in the current high interest rate environment. The benefits of the here and now – unlocking their CRE equity means it's "go time" for deals, unlike the often disparate expectations of a third-party landlord seller. Open Opportunity, With Caveats While there are fewer overall opportunities in the net-lease market compared to the last couple of years, there are fewer market challengers due to the more restricted financing options. “Plenty of investors who were very competitive just a couple of years ago, for example, were reliant on CMBS debt and are now no longer nearly as competitive as they used to be,” Swann says. “And that's given us a leg up.” Office demand continues to suffer from uncertainty, mainly from lagging return-to-office efforts and hard-to-figure valuations given the large amounts of vacant and shadow space. On the plus side, Swann views the industrial sector as the most favored by net lease investors, as strong demand post-COVID for logistics facilities persists, with companies building out their supply chains amid a more general move to on-shoring production. Earlier this year, W. P. Carey completed an approximately $468 million, 20-year lease sale-leaseback with Apotex for a portfolio of pharmaceutical manufacturing assets in the greater Toronto area. Swann points out that the combination of sector (industrial), type (new vs. existing lease) and trend (taking advantage of better cost of capital through a sale-leaseback) all led to the deal getting done. “In a lot of ways I think that Apotex deal is a good example of where the market is going,” says Swann.
Why Net Lease Continues to Draw Investors
The net lease retail sector continues to outperform despite changing interest rates, with a growing number of retailers expanding their footprints or developing new properties against a “compelling” cap rate environment. That’s according to Michael Fitzgerald, executive director, head of US Retail, W. P. Carey, who told GlobeSt at ICSC Las Vegas that many retailers are “aggressively expanding” in their markets. “We’ve seen a lot of activity in sale-leaseback and we are bullish on net lease retail,” Fitzgerald says. “The retail sector is enormous – and we’re chasing deals.” Fitzgerald also discusses: The state of retail fundamentals How investors are responding to changing interest rates and economic uncertainty What makes W. P. Carey stand out from its competitors in terms of investment opportunities Watch now An interview with Michael Fitzgerald, W. P. Carey, and Holly Amaya, GlobeSt.com.
Navigating a Rapidly Changing Retail Industry
Over 20,000 real estate investors, developers, property managers, retailers and brokers convened in Las Vegas last month for the annual ICSC convention. In the midst of a volatile market, attendees sought answers on how to navigate current challenges impacting the retail industry. Below were three of the biggest themes to emerge. Retail resiliency amid market headwinds Just a few years ago, the outlook for the retail industry was grim. Consumers weren’t shopping due to the pandemic, brick-and-mortar stores were closing and many large retailers were filing for bankruptcy. However, the market surprisingly bounced back post-covid as consumers returned to stores with a desire to spend. As the real estate industry as a whole now contends with new challenges including higher interest rates and economic uncertainty, the silver lining is that retail has been somewhat less impacted than other asset classes. Office continues to face return-to-work challenges and industrial is contending with supply chain bottlenecks and overall supply shortages. While retail has not been entirely insulated, the fundamentals have remained quite sound – leasing remains strong, occupancy is high and companies are continuing to announce new store openings. The consensus at ICSC was that there are certainly challenges ahead, but that the retail industry is well positioned to weather the storm and come out in a position of strength. Trend toward mixed-use retail One of the biggest challenges in today’s retail environment is adapting to the growing and changing needs of the everyday consumer. As a result, landlords, retail owners and developers are increasingly exploring mixed-use developments – which blend multiple uses such as retail, residential and entertainment. For instance, a landlord may decide to redevelop an existing retail center by incorporating entertainment facilities, residential apartments and hotel amenities that attract consumers while also helping drive sales and boost profits. Landlords are also embracing a more experiential approach to retail centers by incorporating movie theaters, fitness centers, spas and other lifestyle attractions. Particularly now when ground-up retail development is not the most attractive given the current market, converting existing retail centers into mixed-use sites is a unique way for landlords to maximize value and grab consumer attention. Sale-leasebacks as a solution for rising development costs Rising interest rates continue to impact retail development. Developers’ capital costs have increased drastically, and as a result they are demanding higher asking rents from retailers. This is forcing more retailers to turn toward in-house development, which means the development costs are held on the balance sheet of the company. To offset these costs, retailers are exploring sale-leasebacks – where a company sells its real estate to an investor for cash and simultaneously enters into a long-term lease. This enables the retailer to receive a significant cash infusion while maintaining full operational control of the property. Developers can also take advantage of the sale-leaseback model. If they’re developing a building in which a tenant has already been secured, developers can work with an investor on a forward commitment in which the investor funds construction costs and acquires the building upon completion, or the investor purchases the building once complete. This enables the developer to recoup costs while still collecting a development fee. With an interest rate decrease not likely for 2023, sale-leasebacks are expected to continue growing in popularity for retailers looking to expand their footprints and developers, providing opportunity for investors that specialize in these types of transactions (like W. P. Carey!).
6 Reasons Why Alternative Financing is a Hot Topic for CFOs
In today’s fast-changing environment, CFOs are increasingly focused on transformation and strategically positioning their organization for future success. However, serious financial stressors are making that job difficult, as cash is more difficult to secure. To ensure their business is set up to succeed, CFOs are investigating alternative sources of capital. One such alternative is a sale-leaseback, where a business sells its real estate to an investor for cash and simultaneously enters into a long-term lease. Many predict alternative financing methods, such as sale-leasebacks, will grow in popularity over the next year. Here are six reasons why: Climbing Interest Rates The Federal Reserve hiked interest rates throughout 2022 to tame inflation. This trend is likely to continue in 2023, with the Fed raising interest rates for the 10th time in a row in May in its ongoing efforts to curb inflation. High interest rates make traditional loans expensive and hard for some companies to secure, particularly those that are sub-investment grade. It also makes refinancing more challenging, putting CFOs with debt coming due in a difficult position. The logical option is to find alternative avenues to secure capital to pay near-term debt and create growth opportunities for the future. Inflation Remains High Although inflation has begun to cool, the annual rate as of April 2023 is 4.9%, much higher than the Fed’s target of 2%. As a result, the price of commodities, raw materials and labor remains high, forcing most businesses to eat into their savings to stay afloat. For CFOs looking to develop capital-raising strategies that will provide cash without putting an intense strain on their business, alternative financing methods such as a sale-leaseback are a great option. Looming Possibility of Recession The World Bank has been slashing earlier economic growth figures it had projected, indicating that we may be headed into a recession in the coming months. Global economic growth had been initially projected at 3% but was later reduced to 2%. This reflects the third weakest pace of growth in nearly thirty years, exceeded only by the global recessions caused by the pandemic and the global financial crisis. A recession is extremely difficult on businesses, and often results in significant declines in sales and profits, layoffs, slashed capital spending and restricted financing access. If that's where the economy is headed, the best way for CFOs to prepare is to start looking for alternative financing to increase cash flows and bolster their balance sheets to weather the storm. The Talent War Continues The great resignation took the war for talent to a higher level as labor shortage became rampant, and the skills gap widened even further. Companies are being forced to reskill or upskill to meet current demands. Training magazine shows this data that reveals why reskilling is essential: 57% of US workers want to update their skills, and 48% would consider switching jobs. 71% of workers say job training and development increase their job satisfaction. 61% say upskilling opportunities are an essential reason to stay at their job. 94% of workers would stay at their company if their company invested in their careers. Reskilling takes financing. With the average cost to reskill an employee standing at $24,800, coming up with an actionable capital-raising strategy is critical. Increased Customer Expectations The great resignation took the war for talent to a higher level as labor shortage became rampant, and the skills gap widened even further. Companies are being forced to reskill or upskill to meet current demands. Fast solutions to customer complaints Access to preferred service channels Opportunities to answer questions themselves through help centers Hyper-personalized experiences Data protection and privacy Growing or staying in business is impossible if you can't meet these needs. Recent reports show companies have already begun investing in stellar customer experiences, with those investing in omnichannel experiences jumping from 20% to more than 80%. Also, 84% of companies are focusing on improving mobile customer experience. Because improving customer experience means investing in tech, spending will increase, requiring CFOs to come up with intelligent ways to shore up extra capital. Accelerated Digital Transformation Beyond the rampant use of AI, other disruptive technologies such as blockchain, the cloud and IoT are becoming more common and interdependent in improving business functions. These technologies are not static either but are continually evolving, creating the need for businesses to rethink their structure and ensuring employees across all levels can keep up with the technology. Despite the potential recession and tough economic times, developing solid digital strategies and reviewing existing tools and processes for efficiency gaps will help create a unified approach to digital transformation. As with other processes, transformation requires cash, so CFOs will likely turn toward alternative financing strategies to unlock the capital needed. Final Word 2023 is full of headwinds for CFOs, which will require businesses to explore unique capital strategies to ensure they have the cash needed to succeed. At W. P. Carey, we specialize in sale-leasebacks and work with CFOs to help them monetize their real estate and redeploy that capital back into their businesses. Particularly in today’s economic environment, CFOs will likely find that the rate at which they can monetize their real estate through a sale-leasebacks is more attractive than the current long-term borrowing rate. With significant dry powder, 50 years of experience and the ability to provide certainty of close, W. P. Carey is poised to deliver much-needed capital for companies interested in exploring sale-leasebacks. Contact us today to find out if your company and real estate are a good fit!
How Private Equity Can Leverage Sale-leasebacks
Sale-leasebacks are often used by private equity firms to raise capital to support portfolio company growth. Through a sale-leaseback, private equity firms can unlock otherwise illiquid capital tied up in portfolio company real estate and reinvest the proceeds into its core business. Here’s how private equity firms can leverage sale-leasebacks to generate long-term value: Maximize portfolio company value by reinvesting sale-leaseback capital into its operations Following the completion of a sale-leaseback, private equity firms can immediately invest the proceeds into its portfolio company’s business operations to support long-term growth. These include investments in new facilities, technology, equipment, R&D and human capital. The benefit of pursuing a sale-leaseback instead of other debt alternatives is that PE firms can realize 100% fair market value for the portfolio company real estate. For example, W. P. Carey worked with a middle-market private equity firm on the $19 million sale-leaseback of two industrial facilities leased to a global distributor of plastics. The private equity firm used the transaction proceeds to secure long-term capital to expand portfolio company operations and fund future growth initiatives. Pay down existing debt and provide portfolio companies with balance sheet flexibility Private equity firms can use sale-leasebacks as a method to recapitalize and strengthen the credit metrics of their portfolio companies. Particularly for smaller, non-credit-rated companies that cannot access the capital markets, a sale-leaseback is a great tool to provide balance sheet flexibility and enable portfolio companies to pay down maturing debt and other liabilities. By improving the balance sheet, private equity firms can position a portfolio company for a credit upgrade or even an IPO, maximizing the long-term value of the company. In 2020, W. P. Carey provided a private equity firm $40 million in sale-leaseback financing for a manufacturing facility leased to a global leader in barbecue grills and accessories. Proceeds were used to pay down debt and improve the balance sheet, helping position the company for a positive credit improvement. Shortly after the sale-leaseback, the company completed an IPO raising over $250 million. Compete more effectively for new acquisitions and M&A Sale-leasebacks can be used by private equity firms to help finance add-on acquisitions – where a PE firm acquires a new company and mergers it with an existing portfolio company to generate growth. By carving out real estate from a business during or post-acquisition, private equity firms can unlock substantially higher value for the real estate due to the spread between the lower cash flow multiple paid to acquire the business and the much higher cash flow multiple received from the sale of the real estate itself. As a result, sale-leasebacks are a capital-efficient way to maximize portfolio company growth while also serving as a positive arbitrage opportunity for private equity firms. W. P. Carey worked with a private equity firm on the $29 million sale-leaseback of four industrial facilities leased to a global manufacturer and distributor of vehicle-mounted aerial lifts. Proceeds from the transaction were used to partially fund the manufacturer’s acquisition of a German company in the same industry, enabling them to expand their market share in Europe. Conclusion Sale-leasebacks are a highly attractive capital allocation tool with many strategic and financial benefits for sponsored companies. Real estate financing can be an extremely effective way to fund growth and add value to portfolio companies, particularly in today's high-interest rate environment. In order to maximize proceeds, PE firms considering a portfolio company sale-leaseback should work with an all-equity buyer with experience working with all types of credits. W. P. Carey has partnered with private equity firms and their advisors on these types of transactions since 1973, and has provided over $5.7 billion in capital to PE firms and their portfolio companies. If you’re interested in pursuing a portfolio company sale-leaseback, please contact us at globalinvestments@wpcarey.com.
Retail's Latest Transformation Has Investors Watching
Retail has been the commercial real estate chameleon, changing and adapting with the times, including the rise of e-commerce and COVID-19. The post-pandemic rebirth of the sector has made major headlines and many retail operators and owners see flying colors. Michael Fitzgerald, executive director and head of US retail investments at W. P. Carey, sees three major trends that sector stakeholders should be watching: the strength of needs-based retail, a development switch favoring sale-leaseback investors and the continued recalibration of buyer-seller expectations. Targets & Tactics “An interesting thing about COVID was how resilient certain areas of retail actually were,” said Fitzgerald. “We saw immediate and sustained growth after that short period of shutdowns.” Non-discretionary, core-good retail including grocery stores and services-based tenants, such as auto services, have been “very strong,” according to Fitzgerald. Low-cost discount stores are a good place to do deals given the economic worries. And family entertainment centers, such as arcades and bowling alleys with full-service restaurants, have seen sustained periods of same-store sales growth and high profitability, benefitting from the post-COVID pent-up consumer demand. “When you’re very flexible, have tons of ability to evaluate business models, take a partnership approach and meet with management teams to understand how they position themselves in the market, you’ll have a lot of good investment options,” said Fitzgerald, who prefers master leases of 15- to 25-year term with escalations every five years. “We can do anything from convenience stores to an automotive service business to grocery and sporting goods. We’re pretty agnostic as to the types of retail we pursue.” Rate Responses As the impact of rising interest rates continues to unfold, Fitzgerald has found that most tenants and retailers are somewhat hesitant to raise their prices so as not to alienate or even “destroy” their customer base. There’s an opportunity to boost profitability, but also a concern about the outcome if companies go down that path and then the economic “switch flips” and customers stop spending. Increased interest rates affect retail development negatively, but Fitzgerald believes a specific shift in that regard that could yield investment opportunity. Retailers planning to grow their footprint have traditionally partnered with merchant developers, but with higher capital costs the latter’s return requirements “have increased significantly” and, in turn, their hiked asking rents have forced retailers to look for alternatives. As a result, retailers are doing more of their own development, whether in-house or through fee developers. “So a lot of these developments will be held on the balance sheet of retail companies, which is good because a lot of companies will likely decide to do sale-leasebacks,” he said. “Given that’s our company’s prime target, we think that’s a good trend to come from the higher rates.” Outlook Fitzgerald maintains that it’s still too early to make a prediction for overall transaction volume in the retail sector in 2023, adding that since last fall cap rate expectations have gone up 45 to 50 basis points in many cases. “What we’re seeing is that retailers that need to grow their footprint and monetize new developments are going to meet the market and are going to do deals,” he said. “If retailers continue to meet the market I think it’ll be a good, active year. If there’s a standoff I think it’s going to be more difficult.”
Corporate Capital Outlook - Q1 2023
"The first quarter of 2023 saw significant financial events continuing to cause stress in financial markets, with the Silicon Valley Bank's collapse and Credit Suisse's emergency takeover major contributors. Expected to compound the issue, there is over $2.5tn in commercial real estate debt which will mature in the next five years, with smaller regional U.S. banks holding 70% of outstanding loans to the CRE sector. Rising interest rates and reduced sales volumes will likely cause further defaults in the CRE and banking sector, but overall the global financial system is less exposed compared to the 2008 crash. Q1 2023 experienced the lowest volume of corporate net lease transactions for the past 3 years. The most popular asset class continues to be industrial & logistics followed by office. Despite the sharp rise in European base rates, we have not necessarily seen the mirror image in real estate yields. Written by Colliers Corporate Capital Solutions, the report details the current state of the global economy and capital markets and how that’s impacting the net lease sector. The report also features contributed content from Christopher Mertlitz, Head of European Investments at W. P. Carey, on how corporates can leverage real estate to unlock capital on attractive terms while the debt markets are in flux. Download below to read the full report.
A Bumpy Road Ahead, but Reasons for Optimism: Key Takeaways from MIPIM 2023
Last month, 23,000 CRE professionals traveled to Cannes for MIPIM 2023 – Europe’s largest real estate conference. Attendees soaked in the French Riviera sun on La Croisette as they gathered to discuss today’s real estate market and the potential opportunities and challenges that lie ahead. Shakeups and surprises in the financial markets took center stage, but optimism about the future of the commercial real estate market remained. Here were the three biggest topics that dominated the discussion and our perspective on what it means for the future. Financial market turmoil The conference kicked off amidst the largest banking failure in more than a decade with the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB), followed by the dramatic fall in the stock price of Credit Suisse and the subsequent announcement that UBS would be acquiring the company. The banking sector turmoil became a hot topic of conversation, with delegates divided over the economic impact of these micro-shocks. Some believed the downfall of SVB and Credit Suisse were not a signal for the entire economy, given SVB operated in a very specific ecosystem and Credit Suisse had faced a number of problems going back several years. Others felt it was eerily similar to the bank failures in 2008 and an indication we are moving into a financial crisis. Laser focus on interest rates For some delegates, the outlook off the back of the banking turmoil remained positive, as many thought the banking crisis would help stave off the Central Bank’s appetite for rate increases in their battle against inflation. Ultimately, this proved to be short-lived given the European Central Bank’s decision to raise interest rates across the Eurozone by 0.5 percentage points on March 16 and the Federal Reserve’s move to raise rates by 0.25 percentage points the following week. Interest rates, and the broader discussion concerning the pace of hikes, were topics already in focus long before MIPIM began. However, during the conference, there emerged a growing consensus that we are entering a new stage of the market with higher interest rates likely staying for the foreseeable future and old pricing levels now a thing of the past. Opportunities still available Where to source attractive investment opportunities was another key topic in Cannes. Similar to years prior, logistics led the way with regard to positive investor sentiment. Attendees agreed the fundamentals for the asset class remain strong, although in some markets many pointed out that logistics cap rates were slow to adjust to rising interest rates. Office, on the other hand, has largely fallen out of favor with investors given work-from-home and hybrid schedules remaining in place for many companies. Our perspective If an economic downturn is on our horizon, W. P. Carey is well positioned to weather the storm given we have a 50-year history of operating in all economic cycles. Our portfolio diversification, disciplined underwriting and lease structuring, and our well-positioned balance sheet, make us one of the safest REITs in terms of downside protection. As an all-equity buyer, W. P. Carey also remains well positioned to execute on deals and offer certainty of close given we aren’t reliant on third-party debt financing. For example, we recently announced a cross-border sale-leaseback of an industrial portfolio in Spain and Italy with Siderforgerossi, a leading manufacturer of specialized forged metal components. The facilities represent a significant portion of the company’s manufacturing footprint and are triple-net leased for a term of 25 years with annual rent increases. Despite the bumpy road ahead, I remain optimistic about the future. Rising interest rates make sale-leasebacks a more attractive financing option for corporates on a relative basis, meaning we’ll likely see an influx in opportunities in 2023. We always say that sale-leasebacks are a good tool in good times, but a great tool in uncertain times, and this sentiment couldn’t ring more true than it does today.
It's Sale-Leaseback's Time to Shine
The current capital environment has tested the adaptability of many companies, as increasing interest rates have made the cost of capital rise uncomfortably. And while it’s unknown if recent events will calm the Federal Reserve’s zeal for future hikes, some companies are already availing themselves of an alternative capital source: the sale-leaseback. In fact, the transaction type matched its 2019 peak in Q4 of 2021, and there are signs it may not be slowing. Zachary Pasanen, managing director, investments at W. P. Carey, sees two big factors playing into the current interest in sale-leaseback: cheaper cost of capital and extra liquidity during tough times. A Corporate Alternative to Expensive Capital A major concern for corporate real estate holders is reducing the cost of capital for the next several years. As Pasanen notes, while they are “not quite desperate yet, the lag between interest rates and cap rates hadn’t caught up six months ago, but it’s starting to now. Prudent CFOs are looking to maximize capital and a long-term sale-leaseback is a great way to do that.” A sale-leaseback offers a “naturally accretive” alternative funding source. Holders of good, fungible, mission-critical real estate that are willing to sign a long-term lease with market or better rental increases built in will likely find that the underlying rate with which they can monetize those assets is inside the going long-term borrowing rate, according to Pasanen. The 50-year-old REIT’s predominant focus has been on warehousing, specialty manufacturing and food production, but it also delves into the education and retail sectors, the latter ranging from experiential sites to fitness-related products to auto repair locations. “By and large, we’ll look at anything as long as there’s criticality to it, meaning the stuff is made at our subject facilities or there’s a really strong location story to it or rent coverage or just a good real estate fundamental story,” Pasanen says. A Liquidity Solution for Tough Times Another consideration facing corporate real estate owners is having the capital on hand to weather the current economic instability. Rates again become a major problem, especially for companies or properties that might be lower on the credit spectrum. “For companies facing challenges that don’t have the ability to finance at attractive rates it’s a very simple calculus: if your borrowing costs go up that’s going to eat into your profit margins and there are only so many levers you can play with when operating a business,” Pasanen said. “They have to be laser-focused on how to get through this period of instability and unknowns.” Sale-leasebacks appeal here as well, allowing companies to put money back into their core competencies or pay down shorter-term debt that’s gotten more expensive, or perhaps even expand given that acquisition targets may have become cheaper. But Pasanen also notes that W. P. Carey’s sale-leaseback business is not just a capital product for troubled times, whether or not it’s on top of mind for companies and owners. “A sale-leaseback is a good tool in good times and a great tool in really uncertain times,” says Pasanen.