Food Production
It's Sale-Leaseback's Time to Shine
The current capital environment has tested the adaptability of many companies, as increasing interest rates have made the cost of capital rise uncomfortably. And while it’s unknown if recent events will calm the Federal Reserve’s zeal for future hikes, some companies are already availing themselves of an alternative capital source: the sale-leaseback. In fact, the transaction type matched its 2019 peak in Q4 of 2021, and there are signs it may not be slowing. Zachary Pasanen, managing director, investments at W. P. Carey, sees two big factors playing into the current interest in sale-leaseback: cheaper cost of capital and extra liquidity during tough times. A Corporate Alternative to Expensive Capital A major concern for corporate real estate holders is reducing the cost of capital for the next several years. As Pasanen notes, while they are “not quite desperate yet, the lag between interest rates and cap rates hadn’t caught up six months ago, but it’s starting to now. Prudent CFOs are looking to maximize capital and a long-term sale-leaseback is a great way to do that.” A sale-leaseback offers a “naturally accretive” alternative funding source. Holders of good, fungible, mission-critical real estate that are willing to sign a long-term lease with market or better rental increases built in will likely find that the underlying rate with which they can monetize those assets is inside the going long-term borrowing rate, according to Pasanen. The 50-year-old REIT’s predominant focus has been on warehousing, specialty manufacturing and food production, but it also delves into the education and retail sectors, the latter ranging from experiential sites to fitness-related products to auto repair locations. “By and large, we’ll look at anything as long as there’s criticality to it, meaning the stuff is made at our subject facilities or there’s a really strong location story to it or rent coverage or just a good real estate fundamental story,” Pasanen says. A Liquidity Solution for Tough Times Another consideration facing corporate real estate owners is having the capital on hand to weather the current economic instability. Rates again become a major problem, especially for companies or properties that might be lower on the credit spectrum. “For companies facing challenges that don’t have the ability to finance at attractive rates it’s a very simple calculus: if your borrowing costs go up that’s going to eat into your profit margins and there are only so many levers you can play with when operating a business,” Pasanen said. “They have to be laser-focused on how to get through this period of instability and unknowns.” Sale-leasebacks appeal here as well, allowing companies to put money back into their core competencies or pay down shorter-term debt that’s gotten more expensive, or perhaps even expand given that acquisition targets may have become cheaper. But Pasanen also notes that W. P. Carey’s sale-leaseback business is not just a capital product for troubled times, whether or not it’s on top of mind for companies and owners. “A sale-leaseback is a good tool in good times and a great tool in really uncertain times,” says Pasanen.
What’s Behind Food Production’s Interest in Sale-leasebacks
The food production sector has been a significant source of recent deal flow for W. P. Carey – in 2020 we completed five investments in the sector totaling $210 million. In part, this is due to the overall stability of the industry. Even amid a global pandemic, food is essential, and most food companies have continued to perform well – particularly those with a diversified customer base. As a result, many food production companies are seeking capital to keep up with demand and discovering the opportunities a sale-leaseback presents – the ability to quickly unlock the capital tied up in their commercial real estate to reinvest into their core business. In a sale-leaseback, a company sells its real estate to an investor like W. P. Carey for cash and simultaneously enters into a long-term lease, while maintaining full operational control of the facility. For food production companies, a sale-leaseback can be a critical tool to increase cash flows and support long-term growth. Here’s how: Lock in low rates with a long-term lease and recapitalize balance sheet The COVID-19 pandemic forced many companies to take a hard look at their balance sheets and find opportunities to recapitalize and add working capital. For food production companies that aren’t in the business of owning real estate, those real estate assets can be a significant weight on their balance sheets. A sale-leaseback, particularly in the current low rate environment, can enable them to monetize these assets at a cost that creates a positive arbitrage, given what the capital can earn when those proceeds are invested in their core business. In October, we completed a $34 million sale-leaseback with a food production company in the Midwest where proceeds were used both to pay down debt and add working capital to the balance sheet. In addition, while interest rates currently remain at historic lows, they are expected to rise in the years to come. By pursuing a sale-leaseback and signing a long-term lease now, companies can lock in attractive rental rates for 15 to 30 years. Unlock capital to support new acquisitions and future growth Food production has remained one of the most resilient sectors during the pandemic, with some companies even benefiting from the trends that have emerged – including a greater demand for e-commerce and at-home grocery deliveries. To capitalize on these trends, food production companies are looking to shore up capital for new acquisitions that will support their future growth. Sale-leasebacks are a great method to supply companies with this dry powder, enabling them to act quickly on opportunities and take advantage of the market. Proceeds can also be used for other growth initiatives, including investments in new technology or equipment that will help increase efficiency, improve delivery capabilities and help meet growing demand. Earlier this year, we completed a $75 million sale-leaseback of two packing, production and distribution facilities in California with a leading grower-packer of seasonal, high-value summer fruit in which the proceeds were used to help fund growth initiatives for the company. Secure a long-term capital partner If companies choose the right buyer in a sale-leaseback, not only can they unlock immediate capital, but they can also secure a long-term partner to support ongoing growth and real estate needs. These can be add-on acquisitions, build-to-suits of new facilities or expansions of existing facilities. Particularly as demand for e-commerce is expected to increase, having a long-term capital partner can be a critical component to a company’s growth strategy and give them an edge against competitors. We completed several projects with our existing tenants in the food production sector last year to help support their growth. In June, we completed a $75 million build-to-suit of a brand-new, state-of-the-art food production facility in San Antonio, Texas with our existing tenant, Cuisine Solutions, the largest manufacturer of sous vide food. The facility enabled Cuisine to address growing demand and expanding operations. In addition, we completed a warehouse expansion in an accelerated timeframe in Portugal with our tenant, Sonae MC, a leading Portuguese food retailer, to help them meet rapidly growing demand as a result of the pandemic. In closing As food production companies continue to recognize post-pandemic opportunities for growth and enhanced profitability, demand for attractively priced sale-leaseback capital as a long-term source of funding will increase. The liquidity provided by a sale-leaseback can support a range of corporate initiatives, including balance sheet recapitalization, paying down debt and shoring up working capital for future growth. Thoughtful lease structuring along with timely execution are crucial factors requiring an established sale-leaseback partner with recognized experience, relationships and reputation. In addition, it’s critical to find a partner with a long-term outlook to help fund both current and future needs. At W. P. Carey, we’re a long-term investor and endeavor to support our tenants throughout the duration of their leases so they have the capital and real estate they need to remain successful. If our tenants do well, we do well – it’s a symbiotic relationship.
Why Food Retailers Should Consider Sale-leasebacks to Support Growth Strategies
As many retailers nationwide are forced to close down and reduce property footprints due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, one particular sector is looking to grow – food retail. Driven by changing consumer habits such as eating more at home and the desire to “stock up” on groceries, food retail has seen growing demand in recent months. In fact, a recent survey showed that consumers are spending 37 percent more per grocery trip than they did before the pandemic. In addition, while in-store shopping trips have declined, digital sales continue to boom – with US online grocery sales hitting a record $7.2 billion in June, up 9 percent from May’s $6.6 billion. Despite many food retailers being spared from the financial repercussions of the pandemic, the swift shift towards online shopping has driven savvy retailers to bolster their omnichannel shopping strategies and capitalize on the newfound demand for online delivery. To implement these changes and adapt to growing demand, food retailers will need growth capital for critical projects like investing in their online-ordering capabilities and/or expanding their distribution centers to keep up with online orders. One of the simplest and most effective ways retailers can secure this capital is by leveraging their existing real estate assets and pursuing a sale-leaseback transaction. In a sale-leaseback – or “sale and leaseback” – a company sells its real estate to an investor for cash and simultaneously enters into a long-term lease. In doing so, the company extracts 100 percent of the property’s value and converts otherwise illiquid assets into working capital to grow its business, while also maintaining full operational control of its facilities. One major benefit of a sale-leaseback is that it is generally a long-term commitment, meaning companies can realize high prices for their assets in the current low-yield environment and also lock in low rent for years to come. In addition, companies can gain a long-term capital partner that can fund future expansions and development of new facilities. Because of these benefits, it’s not surprising that several savvy food retailers have already pursued sale-leasebacks as part of their growth strategies on a stand-alone basis or in conjunction with private equity firms and other investors. W. P. Carey is one of the largest diversified net lease real estate investors, with a portfolio comprising over 1,200 properties across both the US and Europe. W. P. Carey has nearly 50 years of experience partnering with creditworthy companies on sale-leasebacks ranging from $5 million - $500 million to help unlock otherwise unused capital tied up in their critical real estate. As consumer habits continue to change due to the pandemic – likely for the long haul – there’s never been a better time for food retailers to undertake a sale-leaseback. Those that do will be able to secure the growth capital they need to expand and meet growing consumer demand and expectations – putting them ahead of the curve and onto the path of long-term success.